Skip to main content

Table 2 Improvement of outcomes in both group

From: The dose effectiveness of extracorporeal shockwave on plantar flexor spasticity of ankle in stroke patients: a randomized controlled trial

Outcome

Baseline

Week 1

Week 4

Week 12

Week 24

p-value†

Primary outcome: MAS

 Double SW group

2.63 (1.09)

2.38 (0.89)

2.13 (1.02)

2.50 (1.03)

2.50 (1.03)

0.043*

 Control SW group

2.56 (0.92)

2.22 (0.94)

2.22 (0.94)

2.44 (1.04)

2.39 (1.04)

0.128

Secondary outcomes

R2-R1 angle of MTS

 Double SW group

16.44 (8.82)

18.31 (9.03)

15.94 (5.84)

19.19 (6.16)

17.50 (5.16)

0.285

 Control SW group

12.50 (11.01)

15.83 (10.04)

13.06 (9.87)

15.56 (8.89)

16.94 (8.77)

0.338

PROM

 Double SW group

44.67 (9.57)

48.13 (9.11)

50.94 (10.04)

48.56 (11.54)

51.38 (8.54)

0.007**

 Control SW group

44.72 (9.31)

49.17 (10.04)

47.78 (11.79)

48.06 (13.41)

49.72 (12.06)

0.181

Timed Up and Go Test

 Double SW group

44.24 (38.82)

34.21 (37.32)

40.16 (52.01)

31.95 (38.20)

30.95 (38.02)

<0.001**

 Control SW group

39.04 (29.71)

37.61 (28.26)

37.80 (31.23)

34.42 (26.80)

35.88 (27.39)

0.114

Barthel index

 Double SW group

68.13 (26.20)

76.56 (18.14)

81.88 (16.42)

83.13 (15.15)

83.75 (15.22)

<0.001**

 Control SW group

66.39 (22.67)

69.72 (22.33)

69.72 (22.33)

70.00 (22.43)

71.11 (23.42)

0.009**

Strain elastography

 Double SW group

1.09 (0.34)

0.94 (0.35)

1.01 (0.38)

1.07 (0.49)

0.98 (0.56)

0.385

 Control SW group

1.10 (0.50)

1.41 (0.71)

0.99 (0.38)

1.04 (0.50)

1.00 (0.39)

0.231

  1. † Friedman test analysis was used for repeated measurements of non-parametric comparison
  2. The data was presented as mean (SD)
  3. Abbreviation: MAS, Modified Ashworth Scale; SW: shockwave; MTS, Modified Tardieu Scale; PROM, passive range of motion; R1, angle of catch seen at quick speed; R2, Full range of motion at slow release of muscle; SD, standard deviation
  4. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01